Arcata1.com on your desktop for a bigger view. Learn more about our city.

No menu items!


HomeGateway PlanFor the Planning Commission & City CouncilRedwood City DTTP - Explore the document

Redwood City DTTP – Explore the document

 


What is the Redwood City Downtown Precise Plan document?

The Redwood City Downtown Precise Plan (DTTP) is a 194-page PDF document, very dense in layout.  It may be considered to be the equivalent of a 300 or 400 page book.  There’s a huge amount of information there, yet it is well-organized and easy to read. The content can be skimmed, with the extensive built-in graphics making it easy to find items of interest.  It is extremely specific in terms of what Redwood City wants developers to follow in their designs.

How can I read the full Redwood City Downtown Precise Plan document ?

Method A:
The Redwood City Downtown Precise Plan can be easily accessed on the Redwood City website by opening the entire plan document here [or stored on this website here].  The Table of Contents is on Page 5. To look up a subject of particular interest to you, you can use the search (Ctrl-F or Command-F) on your viewer/browser to look up a word or phrase, and then jump to that section of the document.  As examples, a search for “bike lane” yields 10 entries; for “urbanism” yields 14; for “shadow” yields 20.

Method B:
Here’s the entire document. You can scroll through it, enlarge (zoom), pan left and right, make full screen, search for words or phrases, and download it if you want.  

Instructions and Suggestions:

  • You can go directly to a Page by typing that number in the page number box and pressing Enter.
  • The ↑ ↓ arrows will go up/down one page at a time. (Arrows may not be on cell screens.) The – + buttons will reduce/enlarge the screen, or the Zoom .  Sorry, pinch doesn’t work.
  • Thumbnails: Press or click the thumbnail icon (at the upper left) to turn thumbnails on or off. 
  • Upside-down?  Many of the posters photos are rotated or upside-down.  To view them correctly, press/click the Tools icon — that will take you to the options for rotating. Rotate two times to correct a photo that’s upside-down.
  • You can cut-and-paste from this PDF viewer.
  • Search:  Want to search for something?  Use the Search button.
  • Print a single page or range of pages.  Or Download the document.

 

[Note to the Reader:  Many of the images in this article are fuzzy.  This is from the process of converting individual PDF pages to photo images (jpg).  This can be improved.  If there is enough interest, I can edit and convert this article use the embedded PDF pages.  The results would be sharper and easier to read.  It that would help you, let me know.]


How long did it take to create?

Redwood City’s Downtown Precise Plan is the result of much concentrated effort through community workshops and by 5 city upper-level staff members and 19 city staff employees, plus other city committees and numerous consultants.

In total, the process took approximately 3 years to develop the Form-Based Code, plus another year or more for the Environmental Impact Report (EIR) — a total of 3 or 4 years to develop a form-based code and an EIR.

Can Arcata benefit from Redwood City’s Precise Plan?

Their plan shows a huge amount of public input, thoughtful consideration, and hard work.  Redwood City is of course far wealthier than Arcata, with a greater amount of money devoted to public services.
 
Possibly the Redwood City DTTP could be used as an outline for Arcata — essentially, could be taken as a model, with numbers and dimensions changed to fit our situation, and alterations made for maps, districts, and architectural features.  That is, where they talk about building heights of 3 to 12 stories, for Arcata that might correspond to building heights of 2 to 6 stories.
 

Comparing the December 2021 draft Gateway Area Plan Arcata with the Redwood City’s Precise Plan

When reading through the Redwood City Precise Plan, the amount of detail and degree of thoughtful consideration are very obvious.  Parts of the plan refer to existing structures — and the need for new structures to be compatible with them — on a neighborhood basis, at times on a block-by-block basis. 

By contrast, Arcata’s draft Gateway Area Plan has four districts, with the main difference being that of height.  (The proposed maximum height is either 5, 6, 7, or eight stories, based on the district.)  In the Arcata plan, there are currently no requirements for differing architectural styles or features within the entire plan.  In the Redwood City plan, there are dozens of very specific requirements.

In essence, the Redwood City plan is fine-tuned.  The Arcata plan is (at this time) generalized and non-specific.


Pages from the Redwood City DTTP

Pages 5-7  Existing buildings and proposed building heights

 

Page 8 – Activity Generating Frontages.
Which streets should have commercial spaces on the first floor ?


 
Public Open Spaces – Page 10

There are 23 public open space areas in the plan. 96% of all parcels in the plan are within a 3 minute walk of an open space. Of the 23 public open space, 10 are designated as “Shadow Sensitive.” Maximum permitted building heights are reduced near these spaces. 

 
 
Page 17 and Page 82 – Lower-height setbacks along the major streets


 
 
 
 

This map shows building heights of 5 to 12 stories.  In Arcata, this might correspond to 2-6 stories.  Note the Yellow zones along the major commercial roads and along much of the perimeter.  This designates where buildings will have a 3-story height along the street, and then a 5 to 8 story height behind that.  In Arcata, this might correspond to a 2 Story height along the pedestrian-oriented streets, and a 4 Story maximum height along commercial streets.


 
Page 27  Flow chart for project approval
Note that there is NOT ministerial review for larger projects.
Planning Commission review and public input is required for projects above 3 stories.  In Arcata, this might correspond to a project above 2 stories, or larger than a certain floor area.
 
Here’s Page 27 from the original PDF document. This becomes readable at about 200%-250% enlargement. You can enlarge (zoom), make full screen, pan left and right, and download it.  (When in full screen, the control buttons are only at the bottom.  You can exit full screen with the button at the BOTTOM of the image.)
 
For quick reference, here are the photo images taken from that page.
Small project review process:
 
 
 
 
Large project review process.  Note the Planning Commission review.
 

 
 
The following pages are included to show the level of detail in the Redwood City DTTP document.  The pages are viewed with more clarity on the PDF file — at the start of this article are the links.
 
Pages 25-29  How to obtain project approval.
Note that there is NOT ministerial review for larger projects.
Planning Commission review and public input is required for projects above 3 stories.  In Arcata, this might correspond to a project above 2 stories, or larger than a certain floor area.
 
 
Pages 84-86.  Height zones, height minimum, Stepdown height zones
Note that in the Redwood City code, the height is measured to the eave or cornice point, and is specified in stories.  In Arcata, height is measured as an overall height to the tallest point of the building, and is specified in feet, i.e. 45-feet would correspond to a 4-story building.
The system of measuring and specifying height in Arcata is considered to be a better and more appropriate method for our town.
 
On Page 85 the stepback required when adjacent to a single-family home.  In Arcata this could be applied when a new building is both adjacent to or across the street from an existing single-family home.
 
 
 
 

 


Be sure to view all the posts on this website about Ministerial Review, Form-Based Code, and how the Redwood City Downtown Precise Plan incorporates Planning Commission / Public Input Review into their process.